A team of researchers at the University of Wyoming have released a report that presents the results of their study comparing two functionally equivalent rural bridges to evaluate sustainability and life cycle cost. They found that the steel bridge outperformed its concrete counterpart across the board.

Over the bridges’ life cycles, the steel bridge will result in 26.3% fewer embodied CO2e emissions, consume 8.7% less energy, and lead to 17.8% more recycled material (assuming the concrete is recycled) at the end of its service life—plus, the steel bridge’s life cycle cost is 23% lower than that of the concrete bridge.

Michael Barker, PE, University of Wyoming’s Civil & Architectural Engineering & Construction Management program, led a team that evaluated two bridges in Whitman County, Wash. Both bridges meet the two-lane rural crossing requirements and were built by the same crew. The study considered only the superstructures of these bridges to allow a direct comparison.

The Seltice-Warner bridge is a roughly 36-ft.-long, prefabricated, modular steel bridge with seven rolled beams and a corrugated gravel deck. The Thornton Depot bridge is a 34-ft.-long, prefabricated, precast, prestressed concrete girder bridge with eight beams and a concrete deck. The Whitman County, Wash. bridge crew built them within the last three years.

Researchers evaluated both bridges throughout their construction, maintenance, and demolition phases according to four sustainability criteria:

Although “the decision on which bridge type to select is clear,” the report says, researchers also developed a series of procedures to help society or a bridge’s owner consider sustainability for more expensive projects.

“The historical decision criteria for choosing which bridge should be built is based on first costs for installing the bridge,” the authors noted. “Responsible owners may also consider life cycle costs over the bridge service life. Neither of these consider sustainability benefits of one bridge over another.

“Sustainable design is predicated on the idea that society is willing to pay extra for reducing harmful effects on the environment. The owner or society determines an acceptable additional cost they are willing to pay for reducing emissions, reducing energy consumption, or reducing material sent to the landfill.”

The American Iron and Steel Institute and Short Span Steel Bridge Alliance provided oversight for this independent research.

The FABRICATOR is North America's leading magazine for the metal forming and fabricating industry. The magazine delivers the news, technical articles, and case histories that enable fabricators to do their jobs more efficiently. The FABRICATOR has served the industry since 1970.

Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The FABRICATOR.

Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The WELDER.

Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The Tube & Pipe Journal.

Enjoy full access to the digital edition of STAMPING Journal, which serves the metal stamping market with the latest technology advancements, best practices, and industry news.

Easily access valuable industry resources now with full access to the digital edition of The Fabricator en Español.

© 2022 FMA Communications, Inc. All rights reserved.

Not yet registered? Sign up